Category Archives: Legal Issues

10.16.09

Legal Issues in Health Reform Symposium

By | Leave a Comment

Please join the O’Neill Institute for our symposium, “State of the Debate: Legal Issues in Health Reform,” on October 26, 2009. “Legal Solutions in Health Reform” is a project of the O’Neill Institute for National and Global Health Law at Georgetown University and funded by the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation.  The project, an extensive analysis […]

Posted in Legal Issues ; Tagged: , , , , , , .

10.14.09

More on Takings

By | Leave a Comment

The individual mandate is not the only provision of the proposed health care reform legislation to raise takings clause issues. All of the bills currently marked up by the jurisdictional House and Senate committees include provision for the establishment of “exchanges” (called “gateways” in the Senate Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions (HELP) Committee bill), which […]

Posted in Legal Issues ; Tagged: , , , , , , , , , , , , .

10.14.09

“Taking” Legal and Economic Liberties, Seriously?

By | Leave a Comment

Constitutional opposition to an individual mandate is usually argued in terms of lack of federal power, but the real motivation is the feeling that a mandate violates individual rights. Opponents would be no less exorcised if a mandate came from the States, which generally have plenary authority over social and economic matters. What basis might […]

Posted in Legal Issues ; Tagged: , , , , , , .

10.13.09

ERISA Preemption and Health Reform: Should the Department of Justice Switch Sides?

By | Leave a Comment

In my article on ERISA preemption for the O’Neill Institute’s Legal Solutions in Health Reform, I argued that pay-or-play initiatives, such as those enacted in Maryland, San Francisco, and Massachusetts, are vulnerable to an ERISA preemption challenge.  Two Circuit Court opinions present the issue directly.  The 4th Circuit overturned the Maryland law based on ERISA […]

Posted in Legal Issues ; Tagged: , , , , , , , .

10.11.09

An Income Tax that Doesn’t Tax Income?

By | Leave a Comment

Tim’s detailed analysis of tax provisions in the Constitution that might apply to health reform is the most thorough I know of, but it only begins to map the issues, which are tricky and important enough that they deserve more attention from constitutional tax law experts. As I synthesize Tim’s points, it seems that the […]

Posted in Legal Issues ; Tagged: , , , , .

10.08.09

Is it a Tax? Is it Constitutional?

By | Leave a Comment

By far the most controversial provision of the health care reform legislation pending in Congress from a constitutional perspective has been the individual mandate. The primary controversy has concerned the issue, which we addressed two weeks ago, of whether the commerce clause authorizes Congress to impose an individual mandate. A different constitutional issue, however, was […]

Posted in Legal Issues ; Tagged: , , , , , , , , , , , , .

10.06.09

Can Tort Reform Bend the Cost Curve?

By | Leave a Comment

On October 6, 2009, the O’Neill Institute hosted a panel on “Medical Malpractice and Health Care Costs: Can Tort Reform Bend the Curve?” to discuss the likely impact of proposed tort reforms on medical mistakes, malpractice system costs, and overall health spending, and why politicians and the press don’t always pay attention to the existing […]

Posted in Legal Issues ; Tagged: , , , , .

10.05.09

Professor Clark Havighurst Responds to Proposal Amending Health Insurance Antitrust Laws

By | Leave a Comment

Recently, Members of Congress have introduced legislation to change the antitrust laws as they relate to health insurance. (See: Modern Healthcare of September 18; free registration is required to view). Some have discussed including such legislation as part of comprehensive health reform. Clark Havighurst of Duke University Law School is the godfather of the field […]

Posted in Legal Issues ; Tagged: , , , , , , , .

09.30.09

A Further Thought on State Nullification

By | Leave a Comment

I would put this a bit more strongly than Mark. Talk of state nullification argues powerfully for the federal government directly enforcing insurance reforms and administering the exchanges and premium subsidies, the approach taken by the House bill HR 3200, rather than depending on the states in implement the reforms, the approach taken by the […]

Posted in Legal Issues ; Tagged: , , .

09.30.09

Civil War Redux

By | Leave a Comment

As Tim Jost well explains, the principle of Federal Supremacy is so well settled that the threat by some state governors or legislators to bar their citizens from complying with federal health care reform is overt legal defiance, or a form of civil disobedience if you will. Civil disobedience might be justified in some circumstances, […]

Posted in Legal Issues ; Tagged: , , , , , .

Stay Informed

Signup for our mailing list and stay up to date on the latest happenings at The O’Neill Institute

Or sign up for our RSS Feed

The views reflected in this blog are those of the individual authors and do not necessarily represent those of the O’Neill Institute for National and Global Health Law or Georgetown University. This blog is solely informational in nature, and not intended as a substitute for competent legal advice from a licensed and retained attorney in your state or country.

See the full disclaimer and terms of use.